Skip to main content

Protesting Vs. Rioting

What Does the First Amendment Say?

    "Congress shall make no law respecting...the right of the people peaceably to assemble" (First Amendment, United States Constitution, 1791.)

    The world we live in today is like no other time in the history of America. We are battling a virus, civil unrest against the government, and civil unrest against each other. True, there is rarely a time where we are in constant "peace," but the last time our country had this much inner turmoil it launched into a civil war. The Black Lives Matter protests have swept the nation and began receiving heavy media involvement since the death of George Floyd. Yes, George Floyd was not the first, nor will he be the last. But his death was at the perfect time to launch our country into the civil unrest we see today.

What Does the First Amendment Allow/Disallow?


    Anyone can protest, for any reason. This is commonly accepted. What causes differing opinions is when these protests become dangerous and harmful to the community. What causes these protests to progress into rioting is also a major talking point. Let's talk about rioting and unlawful assemblies first.

    When a protest turns into a riot or an unlawful assembly, it is no longer protected by the first amendment. What qualifies as a riot or an unlawful assembly? According to Britannica "Riot, in criminal law, a violent offense against public order involving three or more people. Like an unlawful assembly, a riot involves a gathering of persons for an illegal purpose. In contrast to an unlawful assembly, however, a riot involves violence." (Britannica)

    Most, not all, riots start when lawful police action is taken against unlawful assemblies. For example, if there is a protest blocking the street, it is now considered an unlawful assembly because it is causing major disruptions to the general public. Police can now ask the protestors to leave and go to another location. If the protestors do not listen, the police can use non-lethal force to persuade protestors to leave.

    Now let's assume that protestors are following all laws and not causing issues towards the general public. No matter what they are talking about, as long as it's not causing major violence against a person or organization, it is protected under the first amendment right. This means that the government cannot ask them to stop or leave.

    Every situation is different and it would be wrong of us to assume otherwise. To remain respectable Communication Law students, we need to recognize this and view every situation with afresh and non-biased view.



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Cord-Cutting

  Cord-cutting is defined as “the practice of canceling or forgoing a cable television subscription or landline phone connection in favor of an alternative Internet-based or wireless service.” (Oxford dictionary) Basically, it involves moving from live TV services to streaming services. Since the 2020 pandemic, cord-cutting is up by 23% (fortune) and more and more people have been buying internet services.  eMarketer shows that advertisements have dropped over $10 billion and they have projected that it will climb back but won’t reach the original $70.59 billion until at least after 2024. That drop is almost 15% and it hasn’t been this low since 2011 (Tech Crunch).  The math is there if you are wanting to save a buck here and there. With internet costing around $60 a month plus subscription services adding around $30-40, that's still nowhere near what an average cable cost would be. Spectrum offers just internet for $49.99 a month and you can add cable to that for an ...
Post a Comment
Read more

How does social media leave a permanent footprint?

  How does social media leave a permanent footprint? Whatever you put out on the internet, whether that be pictures, timeline posts, your resume, or just your random thoughts, will always be out there. Even if you delete those posts, someone could’ve screenshotted it or recorded it. Along with your social media posts, people can also find out more about you through your credit scores and your bank accounts. With the age of facial recognition, people can find out everything they need to know about you just from a simple picture in a crowded area. Juan Enriquez says that the internet is just as if not more permanent than tattoos and like tattoos they can show the world a specific image or feeling that you are wanting to share. That image can stay around for longer than we are alive. He says that because of this, we are getting close to immortality. Companies can take the info that they learn about you and use it to market their products specifically to you. Enriquez used an example...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Supreme Court

  The Supreme Court The Supreme Court is the head of the judicial branch of the U.S. government. It consists of nine justices and has the power to check the other two branches of government. It was “established in 1789 by Article Three of the U.S. Constitution, which also granted Congress the power to create inferior federal courts” (History.com).  The first Supreme Court justices were sworn in my President George Washington. The original Court only had six justices including Chief Justice John Jay and were to serve until they retired or died.  It wasn’t until 1869 that Congress set the seat number to nine and it has remained that way until today. Their first meeting was on February 2nd, 1790 and were only tasked to work on organization procedures.  They made their first decision on a case on August 3rd, 1971 in West v. Barnes . It was a dispute between a “farmer and a family he owed a debt to” (History.com).  Over the last 200 years, the Supreme Court ...
Post a Comment
Read more